The owner of two reel-to-reel audio tapes containing a one-of-a-kind, superior-quality Beatles concert, recorded directly from the soundboard at Toronto’s Maple Leaf Gardens on Aug. 17, 1965, is ready to sell. Only seven people have purportedly heard the reels, from the show nearly 60 years ago at the height of Beatlemania.

The question now is who will buy it, how much it could be worth — and whether it will ever be released for the public at large to hear it.

“I have never offered it for sale before,” Piers Hemmingsen, a Toronto-based Beatles historian and author of The Beatles in Canada series, tells Billboard. “This is the best recording of any Beatles concert in Canada, if not North America, other than what was professionally recorded for The Beatles themselves.”

Related

For a band as legendary as the Beatles, any rare artifact is likely to draw a horde of prospective buyers. But a singular recording of a concert held at the band’s apex is a rarity among rarities.

Hemmingsen, who has a copy on three cassette tapes for listening purposes only, says the reels contain The Beatles’ entire afternoon set, the opening acts, venue announcements about upcoming events (The Beach Boys, wrestling), and a press conference with The Beatles’ manager Brian Epstein, their PR person Tony Barrow and the BBC’s Brian Matthew, held at the long-shuttered arena’s Hot Stove Lounge.

The Beatles’ set was approximately a half hour long, featuring 12 songs (in order): “Twist and Shout,” “She’s A Woman,” “I Feel Fine,” “Dizzy Miss Lizzie,” “Ticket To Ride,” “Everybody’s Trying To Be My Baby,” “Can’t Buy Me Love,” “Baby’s In Black,” “I Wanna Be Your Man,” “A Hard Day’s Night,” “Help!” and “I’m Down.”

The openers were King Curtis and his Capitol Recording Band (12 songs); Cannibal and The Headhunters (five songs); Brenda Holloway (five songs), and Sounds Incorporated (five songs), who Epstein also repped. In total, the tapes contain 39 songs.

Hemmingsen’s first-look letter — a sell-sheet of sorts outlining the opportunity to purchase the tapes that was shown exclusively to Billboard — says the original concert tapes are “available now for the first time privately, to select individuals who resonate with their rarity and historical imperative.” And one appraiser who spoke with Billboard estimated that the reels could be valued at between $60,000 and $80,000, and could go at auction for as much as $100,000 or more. But the only potential buyer with the ability to release the recording to the public would be Apple Corps — and so far, there has been no offer.

According to Hemmingsen, the soundboard recording was organized by former Toronto Argonauts football player and two-time Grey Cup champion Don “Shanty” McKenzie, who after retiring from the Canadian Football League (CFL) worked for 40 years as the building superintendent for Maple Leaf Gardens. He passed away in 2001.

Hemmingsen views himself as a “custodian” of these tapes and realizes he is not able to share them publicly because Apple Corps owns the rights. (Apple Corps is aware of the recording but declined to comment when reached by Billboard.)

While doing years of research for his 2016 book, The Beatles In Canada: The Origins of Beatlemania! (Red Book), Hemmingsen discovered the existence of a black and white 8mm home movie McKenzie shot, without sound, of The Beatles’ Sept. 7, 1964, concert at the Gardens. He bought the film from McKenzie’s son around 2010, who threw in the two reels.

Related

“When I had bought the items, it was really just for the film, which was not the original but a copy,” says Hemmingsen, a collector himself who recently curated and loaned many of his treasures to the Beatles exhibit that opened last month at Calgary’s National Music Centre, titled From Me To You: The Beatles in Canada 1964-1966. “I certainly wasn’t expecting to find out what was on those two reels. I still find it hard to believe.”

Hemmingsen would not tell Billboard what he paid McKenzie’s son for the film and the reels, but says it was “not expensive” because they did not know what was on the tapes at the time. “I took a risk in buying them, as it took a while before I could locate a proper player and listen to them,” he says. “The tape boxes were not dated.”

The Aug. 17, 1965, concert was The Beatles’ first after their show at Shea Stadium in Queens, N.Y., on Aug. 15, which opened their 1965 North American tour with an attendance of 55,600. The famous footage of that concert showcases the “Beatlemania” that had taken hold, as well as why the live bootlegs in circulation and posted online are not good quality.

“Most of these recordings captured only the sounds of the audience’s screams of delight at seeing The Beatles,” begins Hemmingsen’s first-look letter. “This live recording, made on professional equipment by a sound engineer from Toronto’s Maple Leaf Gardens stage soundboard on August 17, 1965, is the finest live recording made in Canada during their touring years.”

Hemmingsen says he has not made duplicates of the cassettes or even played it for friends over the years. Only a select group of people have heard it, he says, including former Canadian concert promoter John Brower, who put on the famed Toronto Rock and Roll Revival music festival in 1969 and is helping with the sale of the tapes; and Doug McClement, who he describes as “one of Canada’s most respected sound engineers.”

More importantly, several individuals who are intimately involved with the Beatles’ legacy have listened to the recording. After bringing the tapes to the attention of Apple Corps, Hemmingsen says the company flew him to Abbey Road Studios in July 2015, where he “auditioned” the original reel on their equipment. He tells Billboard four people were there: Abbey Road producer Giles Martin (Beatles’ producer George Martin’s son); Jonathan Clyde, director of production at Apple Corps; Sean Magee, mastering engineer at Abbey Road; and Lester Smith — the technician and “microphone custodian” who retired only a week ago from Abbey Road after 56 years — who set up the tape equipment.

“That was for their project Eight Days a Week, the Ron Howard movie,” says Hemmingsen of the meeting. “Now, it turned out that at that time, they said they could not use it for that project and that didn’t mean that they wouldn’t be able to do anything else with it later, but that’s how we left it.”

Related

He adds that when he heard the recordings via a recording studio console, “it was a revelation. It is just like being on stage with them.”

Billboard’s attempts to reach Martin were unsuccessful.

Hemmingsen says the tapes were authenticated by Apple Corps and Magee. Reached by email, Magee told Billboard he is not authorized to comment about what he heard without permission from Apple and Universal Music Group.

He adds that earlier this year, Universal Music Canada’s director of catalogue marketing, Warren Stewart, heard some “sample clips” and that two “sample clips” were sent to filmmaker Peter Jackson “this week for his evaluation,” given the MAL software technology he used to enhance the recordings for the documentary series he directed and produced, The Beatles: Get Back.

Hemmingsen says he would like to keep the cassette copy but that everything is negotiable “if somebody absolutely insists that I give it up.” He wasn’t prepared to tell Billboard the dollar figure he has in mind but plans to use any proceeds to fund both the printing of his next book, The Beatles in Canada: The Evolution 1964-1970 (Blue Book), set for release in September; and a second edition of his The Beatles In Canada: The Origins of Beatlemania! (Red Book).

The Beatles played just nine concerts in Canada, six of which were at Maple Leaf Gardens: two on Sept. 7, 1964; two on Aug. 17, 1965; and two on Aug. 17, 1966. Hemmingsen also owns the only other known Toronto recording from one of the 1966 concerts, which he obtained on eBay in 2008 from a U.S. seller and donated to the University of Toronto in 2017.

“The value given by the University’s appraiser was $30,000 [Canadian dollars; USD $22,000],” he says. “If you compare something that’s been spread around the world to something that they haven’t heard before, which is superior audio quality, I think there’s a factor of five, at least.”

To try to estimate the value of this one-of-a-kind board recording based purely on the description of what the two reels contain, Billboard reached out to U.K.-based music memorabilia and vinyl specialists Omega Auctions Ltd., which has a Beatles auction coming up Oct. 8 and is inviting consignments.

Related

“We’ve sold lots of Beatles recordings down the years. That’s our niche,” says auction manager Dan Muscatelli-Hampson, citing a recent audio tour diary Ringo Starr made in 1966, which sold for £10,000 ($13,000) and a set of unheard interviews, which sold for £30,000 ($39,000).

“Concert recordings are different and are, obviously, more interesting than interviews and will have a greater value, but the key thing is that what you can do with this is limited,” he continues. “If you bought this, you’ve got a really cool reel. But if you ever tried to do anything with it commercially, Apple and Paul McCartney would sue you to the next century. So that limits the commercial value.

“But I think that if you were to put it into auction, you might be thinking around I would probably say something like 40 to 60 thousand pounds,” he adds. “So that’s maybe $60,000 to $80,000, but that’s a provisional auction estimate; I would not be surprised to see it selling upwards of $100,000.”

Muscatelli-Hampson says Hemmingsen “will always be better served putting it into auction, opening up that by a pool rather than just go for the first offer that he gets from Apple. [But] some people like to close that loop and get it back to the people who might be able to do something with it.”

Hemmingsen’s preference would be for Apple Corps to purchase the tapes and release the concert for all to hear. He hopes it will be made available to Beatles fans before the 60th anniversary of the Toronto concert next year.

“You can’t sit on a thing like this,” Hemmingsen says. “You want to share it with the world. On the other hand, there’s a commercial value to it and the only people that can release it are Apple. Somebody could buy the tape from me and enjoy it for themselves, but they could never release it. I have that in writing from Apple. I mean, there’s nothing I can do with it.”

Amid the chart-topping success of “A Bar Song (Tipsy),” Shaboozey is now suing music publisher Warner Chappell — claiming the company is stonewalling his efforts to exercise a contractual provision that would give him an early exit from his deal.

In a case filed Wednesday (Aug. 21) in Los Angeles, the country star (born Collins Obinna Chibueze) claims his publishing administration deal with Warner-Tamerlane (a unit of Warner Chappell) contained an acceleration clause — meaning he could repay 110% of advances to speed up the expiration of the deal.

Related

Shaboozey’s lawyers say he invoked that clause last month — perhaps unsurprisingly, given the massive success of “Bar Song.” But they claim Warner has, thus far, declined to even tell him how much is owed.

“To date, Warner has refused to disclose to plaintiff the total amount of the unrecouped balance of prior advances it made,” writes Todd Bonder, the star’s attorney. “Warner’s conduct violates the administration agreement signed between the parties.”

The lawsuit comes amid a breakout year for Shaboozey. “A Bar Song,” a genre-blending hit that interpolates J-KWON‘s 2004 rap hit “Tipsy” into a bouncy pop country track, has spent six weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100, tying the longest chart-topping stint for a song in 2024.

In his complaint, Shaboozey also names his former record label, Kreshendo Entertainment, as a defendant. He claims the company — which he left in 2019 before signing a new record deal with Empire — is the reason Warner is refusing to turn over the crucial information.

“Kreshendo and [others] have instructed Warner not to provide plaintiff the total unrecouped balance related to advances made with respect to the compositions or has refused to authorize Warner to provide such information,” his lawyers write.

The dispute appears to turn on Shaboozey’s argument that he personally took over Kreshendo’s role in the contract with Warner after he terminated his label. In his legal filings, he says that Warner “has not agreed” with such an interpretation.

The lawsuit also claims that Kreshendo released three separate Shaboozey songs in 2019 after he had already terminated the deal — “More,” “Joan Jett” and “Prosperity” — without his permission.

A spokesman for Warner Music Group did not immediately return a request for comment. A spokesperson for Kreshendo could not immediately be located for comment. A publicist for Shaboozey did not return a request for comment.

None of this was promised for Travis Scott — from couch surfing in Los Angeles with rap dreams, to becoming the king of his hip-hop generation, with brand deals from Audemars Piguet to McDonald’s.

While he can look back on his 2014 fondly, there were definitely pockets of creative frustration at the time, when label executives didn’t trust La Flame’s futuristic vision — even after co-signs from the likes of Ye and Jay-Z.

Before the arrival of his debut album, Scott heated up with his second — and likely final — mixtape Days Before Rodeo. With the project celebrating its 10th anniversary earlier this week, and hitting streaming services for the first time, Trav took fans back to 2014 for one night only on Thursday (Aug. 22) inside the tight confines of Atlanta’s The Masquerade.

In collaboration with Cactus Jack and Spotify, the Days Before Rodeo concert served as a victory lap and blast from the past for La Flame, while some Gen-Z Ragers were introduced to the era. At the time, the music world didn’t understand the seismic shift that was about to take place between Scott’s mainstream explosion on the horizon, and Atlanta moving into the spotlight as America’s rap capital.

Fittingly, with Scott signed in part to T.I.’s Grand Hustle Records at the time (the deal has since expired, post-Astroworld), ATL heavily influenced the mixtape — with guest appearances by Migos, Young Thug, Peewee Longway, Rich Homie Quan and Tip (who doesn’t appear on the streaming services version).

The Houston native took The Masquerade stage around 11:30 pm ET following a brief set from Chase B where he was serenaded by the 1,000 lucky fans in attendance who formed plenty of sweaty mosh pits throughout the raucous show while rocking 10th anniversary DBR and Free Thugger merchandise in the intimate setting.

From the reckless “Mamacita” to the lucid “Drugs You Should Try It” and a Quavo appearance, Scott ran through just about the entire mixtape, before introducing tracks from the vault that didn’t make the original’s cut for the first time live.

If only the palpable energy could be bottled up forever — Trav didn’t want the show to stop there, as he continued to play the hits from his relentless discography to keep the rage going. Salute to La Flame for remembering all of his lyrics with ease too. Here are our eight favorite moments from the show.

Jenny From the Block wants to go back to one. In a copy of her divorce filing from Ben Affleck filed on Tuesday (August 20) obtained by Billboard, Jennifer Lopez requested that her former name be restored. So, after two years as Jennifer Lynn Affleck, JLo asked the court to revert her name back to Jennifer Lynn Lopez.

Related

Additionally, the This Is Me… Now singer asked the state of California to deny her and Affleck the chance to collect spousal support. While neither Lopez nor Affleck have made public statements on their split — which came precisely two years after their lavish wedding in Georgia — NBC News cited an unnamed source close to Lopez saying that the couple did not have a prenuptial agreement.

The dissolution of Lopez’s fourth marriage came after she and Affleck reunited and got engaged in 2022. Their unexpected get-back took place more than 20 years after they first got engaged following their meeting on the set of the widely panned film Gigli; the couple split two years later without marrying. Lopez was married to Ojani Noa from 1997-1998 and then to dancer Cris Judd from 2001-2003. She married singer Marc Anthony in 2004 and they were together for a decade, during which she gave birth to twins Emme and Max.

In addition, Lopez was engaged to Yankees player Alex Rodriguez for three years (2019-2021) before she rekindled her romance with Affleck; the couple was commonly referred to by their celeb portmanteau: “Bennifer.” The story of their rebooted romance was chronicled in a pair of projects this year, one telling the story of her most recent album, the cameo-packed fictional retelling of their romance, This Is Me… Now: A Love Story, as well as the accompanying documentary, The Greatest Love Story Never Told.

In addition to taking fans behind the scenes of the making of the This Is Me… Now album — which featured several homages to her second Affleck love affair and served as a sequel to 2002’s Affleck-dedicated This Is Me… Then — the doc featured scenes of a taciturn-looking Affleck seemingly cringing at the sharing of his personal love notes to her.

Interest in the latter doc — which, like the fictional extended music video short film, was widely panned upon initial release — skyrocketed in the 24 hours after the divorce news broke. According to Luminate, U.S. viewership of the Prime Video movie jumped from 10.7k minutes watched on Tuesday’s filing date to 354.1k minutes watched on Wednesday (Aug. 21), marking a 3,000% increase in just one day.

When you’re in between streams of Sabrina Carpenter’s new album (or done watching that clip of her and Jenna Ortega sharing a kiss), why not listen to some new tunes from your favorite queer artists? Billboard Pride is proud to present the latest edition of Queer Jams of the Week, our roundup of some of the best new music releases from LGBTQ artists.

From Doechii’s banging new single to Yaeji’s bouncing new track, check out just a few of our favorite releases from this week below:

Doechii, “Boom Bap”

If you think you know what to expect from Doechii’s new single, let us be the ones to break it to you — you’re wrong. From the moment “Boom Bap” begins, Doechii makes it clear that she’s done with being put in boxes, snarling at her listener that “they said they want me to rap.” What follows is just over two minutes of the Florida rapper flexing her credentials — constant beat switches and style shifts can’t interrupt Doechii’s A+ flow as she proves herself over and over as the one to watch in the hip-hop genre.

Yaeji, “Booboo”

Yaeji is back, folks. With “Booboo” the transformational dance star is ready to fill dance floors and playlists alike. Over a simple-yet-relentless dance beat, Yaeji switches effortlessly between Korean and English to offer the same simple instructions to her listeners — dance. As the song picks up so does the prodcution, exploding into a thundering dance banger that proves to be utterly irresistible for anyone who hears it. If you’re looking to bounce this weekend, look no further.

Blondshell, “What’s Fair”

Sabrina Teitelbaum is here to give you what you hope to hear on a Blondshell record — a classic alt-rock sound with some tough lyrics. “What’s Fair” fulfills the Blondshell promise and even evolves it to a new level of excellence, as Teitelbaum delivers an instantly-lovable pop song that will have you doubling back to its lyrics by the end of the first listen. Written about a fraught mother-daughter relationship, “What’s Fair” makes ample use of the singer’s internal angst to help you expel some of yours.

Katie Gavin, “Casual Drug Use”

We’ve all got our coping mechanisms, and Katie Gavin is ready to talk about it. “Casual Drug Use,” off the MUNA singer’s much-anticipated solo debut, charts the fallout from a previous relationship as Gavin spirals down into the song’s titular activity. She’s quick to make no judgement, instead showing empathy for her past self and her self-soothing mechanisms — which is made even sweeter by the single’s hazy, feel-good sound.

Zolita, “Hypocrite”

Speaking of coping mechanisms, rising pop singer Zolita has got her own — and if she found out her ex was doing the same thing, she’d be pissed. On “Hypocrite,” Zolita nails her particular brand of pop-rock flavor yet again, this time to soundtrack a story of sleeping around, being messy and refusing to feel bad about it. Sure, she might be a “Hypocrite,” but if this is how being hypocritical sounds, then sign us up.

Morgan Saint, “Blazing”

Morgan Saint would just like to know why a breakup has to be dramatic. In her new track “Blazing,” the rising singer tackles the charged dynamics of a relationship headed for disaster, wondering aloud why everything has to end in a blaze of glory. It might sound like a lot, but Saint does a marvelous job blending the implosive subject matter with a blissful, lo-fi pop sound, making “Blazing” the kind of balanced listening experience that will key you up right before it mellows you out.

Check out all of our picks below on Billboard’s Queer Jams of the Week playlist:

Universal Music Publishing Group earned the top spot on the Hot 100 Songs publishers ranking for 2024’s second quarter with 27.97% of the market, in large part thanks to Taylor Swift and the 19 songs she landed on the chart. It didn’t hurt that her writing partner Jack Antonoff is also on UMPG’s roster. (He moved there from Sony Music Publishing in August 2023.) Swift’s work accounted for a little over one-third of the 56 songs the publisher had on the Hot 100 during the quarter, up significantly from its 43-song count in the first quarter of the year.

Sony Music Publishing, which typically places first on the Hot 100 publishers ranking, finished a close second with a 27.13% market share and 57 tracks on the chart, including the No. 1 song for the second quarter, Tommy Richman‘s “Million Dollar Baby.” Warner Chappell Music finished third with a 19.87% market share. Its top second-quarter tune was “A Bar Song (Tipsy)” by Shaboozey, one of 47 that it landed on the chart.

Related

Sony nevertheless remained at the peak of the Top Radio Airplay ranking for the 13th consecutive quarter, with a 27.64% market share and 66 songs. Its No. 1 track was “Lose Control” by Teddy Swims, a song in which Warner Chappell and UMPG also have stakes. Sony was also buoyed by the quarter’s biggest Radio Airplay hitmaker — Ashley Gorley, co-writer of “I Had Some Help” by Post Malone featuring Morgan Wallen — plus seven other songs on the chart.

Warner Chappell maintained its second-place ranking among Top Radio Airplay publishers for the third consecutive quarter with a 23.25% market share and 63 songs on the chart. UMPG came in third with 15.82% of the market and 43 songs.

Kobalt held its position as the fourth-largest  publisher on the Hot 100 and Top Radio Airplay charts with market shares of 10.74% and 9.44%, respectively, in part due to stakes in the No. 1 songs on both charts.

Despite a tumultuous first half of the year, Hipgnosis turned in a strong performance, finishing fifth on both rankings, with a 4.36% share on Top Radio Airplay and 2.73% on the Hot 100, also thanks to its piece of "Lose Control." Last quarter, Hipgnosis — whose founder and CEO, Merck Mercuriadis, stepped down in July after private equity firm Blackstone acquired its catalog — was No. 7 on Top Radio Airplay and No. 9 on the Hot 100.

Related

BMG ranked No. 6 on both Top Radio  Airplay (3.36%) and the Hot 100 (1.47%), down  from the No. 5 ranking it had on both charts in  the first quarter.

Three independent publishers fill the entries at Nos. 7, 8 and 9 on the Hot 100 chart. Reservoir Music ranked seventh (1.34%) thanks to its share of "Espresso" by Sabrina Carpenter, Position Music (1.194%) was eighth due to its stake in "Beautiful Things" by Benson Boone, and Sentric Music Publishing was ninth (1.192%) with help from "End of Beginning" by Djo. The latter two publishers make their first appearances on the rankings.

Last Quarter: Jack Harlow Helped Sony Sweep (Again)

She’s working late, ’cause she’s a singer — and if all goes well, a Broadway actress, too. On a new episode of Chicken Shop Date posted Friday (Aug. 23), Sabrina Carpenter addressed whether she’d ever return to the stage and talked all things espresso, Valentine’s Day and NSFW lyrics.

Related

After conversing with the “Feather” singer about British people’s texting habits and the financial benefits of going on dates, host Amelia Dimoldenberg asked her guest a question that’s been on the minds of many fans since Carpenter’s run as Cady Heron in the Mean Girls stage production was cut short by the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020: “Would you do Broadway again if the right opportunity came?”

“I would,” Carpenter replied with a shrug, smiling.

Four years prior, Carpenter starred alongside Reneé Rapp’s Regina George in the Broadway adaptation of the 2004 movie, but she only got to do a couple performances before it closed down due to the global pandemic. She never did get to reprise her role in the production, as it didn’t reopen at the August Wilson Theatre, nor did she appear in the 2024 movie version of the musical, which Rapp led.

Related

Throughout the interview with Dimoldenberg, Carpenter also shared what she did on Valentine’s Day this year — “I was given chocolate, and I ate it … that was my day” — although she didn’t specify whether she spent the holiday with boyfriend Barry Keoghan. She did, however, explain that she doesn’t fall in love as quickly anymore as she did when she was younger. “Now I fall in love a little more — I don’t want this to sound sad, but I just maybe fall in love with some more knowledge,” she said.

At the end of the video, Carpenter helped Dimoldenberg write an NSFW rhyme to the line, “Went to London ’cause I had a hot date,” in the style of her famous “Nonsense” outros. “I would’ve done something really crazy,” she said, “but I don’t think I can say it on camera.”

Covering her mouth, the Work It actress then whispered her idea: “Later I’m going to get my p—y ate.”

The cheeky interview arrives on the same day as Carpenter’s sixth studio album, Short n’ Sweet, which features hit single “Espresso” and Billboard Hot 100-topper “Please Please Please.” The star also unveiled a gory music video costarring Jenna Ortega, in which they channel the 1992 film Death Becomes Her and bond over killing a man they were previously fighting to the death over.

Speaking of “Espresso,” Carpenter addressed on Chicken Shop Date whether she actually enjoys sipping on the concentrated caffeinated beverage in real life. “I do — I just have to brave through them when I drink them,” she told Dimoldenberg. “It’s not like I like them because of how they taste — I like them because of how they make me feel.”

Watch Carpenter on Chicken Shop Date above.

With the first quarter of the 21st century coming to an end, Billboard has been looking back on the 25 Greatest Pop Stars of the Past 25 Years. Below, we take a deeper look into the peak of our No. 24 pop star, Ed Sheeran, and how his writing style — while often critically derided — actually displays the efficiency, creativity and originality of a true songwriting savant.

Despite being one of this century’s most successful musicians by pretty much any statistic you could conjure, Ed Sheeran’s music has inspired well over a decade’s worth of eye rolls and turned-up noses – not necessarily because it’s bad, in the eyes of critics, but because it’s boring.

That’s not an oversimplification. In 2011, The Guardian’s Peter Robinson literally made the English singer-songwriter the face of “The New Boring,” calling his debut album + “a 12-bore s–tgun” and likening him to “a combination of every friend-of-a-friend’s band whose pub gig you have ever witnessed.” Six years later, Pitchfork’s Laura Snapes described Sheeran as “trite,” “bland” and “unimaginative,” all within the sub-headline of a review about his third album ÷ (it scored a 2.8). For the duration of his career, the musician has been especially critiqued for his approach to genre, cherry-picking features of hip-hop, R&B and rock and distilling them into compressed, radio-friendly pop earworms which inevitably become lodged for years at a time on the charts and on grocery store speakers — writer Rachel Aroesti recently described the end result as a “sludgy, vague, inoffensive post-genre sound that has served to homogenise music in general.”

It’s understandable why people might be so tempted to explain away Sheeran’s success. Homely, scruffy and pointedly underdressed, he soared into the general public’s consciousness as the total antithesis to the polished male pop stars who were big before him — Justins Timberlake and Bieber, One Direction, Bruno Mars – prompting confusion as to how exactly he was able to infiltrate their sleek ranks. But as the essays have piled up over the last 15 years dismissing his scrappy image and mass-appeal music as calculated ploys to maximize profit by appearing as relatable to consumers as possible, one salient quality of Sheeran’s superstardom seems to have fallen out of focus. His seamlessly packaging together the shiniest parts of different genres and presenting them in a way that’s almost universally palatable is a skill in and of itself, and one with which Sheeran is singularly gifted.

It takes an intriguing musical vocabulary, for instance, to infuse a romantic folk ballad such as “Lego House,” one of Sheeran’s earliest hits, with mile-a-minute rap bars — “And it’s dark in a cold December/ But I’ve got you to keep me warm…” in the pre-chorus, without interrupting its cozy pacing. The same can be said of his 2014 smash “Sing,” which somehow has all the body and elasticity of a FutureSex/LoveSounds banger – producer Pharell Williams once told Billboard the Timberlake album was a key inspiration — while staying simultaneously grounded in acoustic instruments and Sheeran’s rapid-fire rhyming. Other hits like 2014’s R&B-rap-pop-dance number “Don’t” and 2017’s tropical 12-week Billboard Hot 100-topper “Shape of You” show off his proclivity for complementing catchy sung melodic hooks with percussive rap-based verses, which he can confidently weave in and out of without ever disrupting the overall feel of a song.

Though he’s never been the most prosaic writer, the words he does choose instead serve to fit snugly in rhyme pockets or push the momentum of a section forward. While certainly cheesy and not particularly clever, the lyrical and melodic simplicity of “I’m in love with the shape of you/ We push and pull like a magnet do/ Every day discovering something brand new” enables it to wedge instantly into listeners’ memories. On the verses, he creates pleasing, percussive toplines that aren’t weighed down by needless syllables, but still manage to propel the narrative forward by quickly summarizing storylines (“One week in, we let the story begin/ We’re goin’ out on our first date”) or tapping into multiple layers of meaning (“We talk for hours and hours about the sweet and the sour…”)

There have been some clunkers in his catalog, for sure: references to Shrek and a—hole bleaching have provided certain songs with needless blemishes, yes. But through all his genre-hopping and unorthodox wordplay, at the very least he can say he’s forged a style that’s entirely his own. His mass appeal may make him “generic” by definition, but his sound is his: Even the successors to his guy-with-a-guitar pop-rock mantle – Shawn Mendes, Lewis Capaldi, Noah Kahan — haven’t once gone near the playful experimentation Sheeran cut his teeth on, instead favoring safer, more traditional songwriting structures.

It’s also notable that Sheeran has never been dishonest about where his scattered musical influences came from, nor has he ever lazily copied anyone else. He’s always stated his love for figures like Damien Rice, Eminem and Eric Clapton, and he worked exclusively with grime artists on the self-released 2011 EP No. 5 Collaborations Project. And at a time where any male artist with his tastes would’ve earned far more cool points by positioning himself as an aloof rock star in the vein of Oasis or Arctic Monkeys, he instead fully, authentically embraced the world of pop and its leaders, teaming up with Taylor Swift on “Everything Has Changed” in 2013 and penning hits for Biebs and 1D’s (2012’s “Little Things” and 2015’s “Love Yourself,” respectively.)

Greatest Pop Stars of the 21st Century Ed Sheeran

All of this to say, maybe Sheeran’s songs aren’t just soulless composites of popular genres designed to be as widely played as possible, but the natural blended output of a guy with a genuine love and appreciation for all the styles he employs. He also happens to be very strategic when assembling those puzzle pieces in a song, preternaturally sensitive to which elements are most likely to make for a successful hit – a personal goal he’s long been transparent about chasing. (“I have a data sheet emailed to me every week,” he told GQ in 2017. “My benchmark for the second album was Coldplay. This album it’s Springsteen.”)

The spectrum of his sound runs parallel to how much he does or doesn’t tailor songs for commercial success. On one end there’s the smoke-blowing songs like 2011’s “You Need Me, I Don’t Need You” and 2017’s “New Man” where he fully indulges his love for loose, slightly silly rapping. Though they might become fan classics, they’re the least programmed to become global hits — he’s just having some fun. On the other end are his sweeping romantic ballads like “Thinking Out Loud,” “Photograph” and “Perfect,” which are maniacally constructed for decades of play at weddings and high school dances. But of these, ask yourself: if not Sheeran, who else is up to the task of pumping out this generation’s deck of timeless sappy slow-dance songs?

In the middle is everything else, the so-called homogenized, post-genre songs that have a little something for everybody. There are several different outcomes songwriters pursue when writing music, and consequently, there are just as many measures of that music’s quality. None are necessarily right or wrong. Swift’s goal is to tell personal stories through her songs. Pitbull wants people to dance. Adele aims to pack an emotional punch. And each of these objectives requires a great deal of craftsmanship when putting pen to paper. Even if Sheeran’s desire has been to write songs surgically stitched together for easy listening, does he really forfeit any recognition for being one of his generation’s most innovative songwriters just because his music is created with algorithmic precision?

When one of his songs ultimately gets stuck in your head for weeks, you might curse his formula as being that of an evil genius. But the key word here is still “genius.”

They say you should never meet your heroes. Well, they never told Jelly Roll that, because in a new behind-the-scenes video posted on Thursday (August 22) the “Save Me” country star details the out-of-body experienced he had in June when he flew to Detroit to meet his hip-hop top dog: Eminem.

Related

The five-and-a-half minute clip opens with Jelly on the phone telling someone that he’s on his way to meet Slim Shady as he speeds down the highway with a police escort. In the clip, Jelly explains that his early morning road trip came after he played two shows at Nashville’s Grand Ole Opry the night before, a whiplash of back-to-back career pinnacles that are truly hard to comprehend.

“I am fixin’ to meet Eminem. To some degree one could say we’re going from the Grand Ole Opry to meet Eminem,” he says while riding in the backseat of an SUV and stating the obvious, but also possibly talking himself off a ledge of disbelief at his good fortune. He explains that the trip was sparked by Marshall tapping him to sing in a Bob Seger tribute as part of the NBC Live From Detroit: The Concert at Michigan Central special that aired in June featuring Diana Ross, Jack White, Big Sean, Eminem and others celebrating the re-opening of the city’s restored train station.

In the prime-time show, Jelly took the stage with event co-producer Eminem for a duet on Em’s 2002 song “Sing For the Moment.”

“Forty-year-old Jason DeFord is losing his mind,” Jelly says using his birth name. “Because I know for sure that 15-year-old Jason DeFord would faint! This is unreal, it’s really cool” he adds, staring out the window and contemplating this surreal moment. He then breaks down the mechanics of rappers expanding their local or regional fame to larger areas while recalling his attempt to break into the game more than a decade ago.

“Guys like Eminem were proud to be from Detroit, Michigan because superstars don’t come out of Detroit, Michigan,” he says, rehearsing an a cappella run of Aerosmith’s “Dream On,” which is interpolated in the Eminem song the duo performed. “We’re in the middle of some insanely historical s–t.”

Walking into the station and taking the stage for rehearsals, the big moment when the two men finally meet comes about half-way through the video. After a friendly greeting, Jelly admits to Marshall that he’s been “a little nervous” all day about their meet-up, wondering if the rap god even knows who he is. “Nah, I’ve been knowing you for a minute,” says a low-key Slim Shady.

Later, Jelly says that moment — standing next to Eminem and taking some promo shots — was on his Mount Rushmore of personal high points, along with meeting Garth Brooks and Dolly Parton. “Where I literally stood next to somebody and was like ‘this is f–king wild!,’” he says before picking out his wardrobe for the performance and having a chill hang with fellow performer Melissa Etheridge backstage.

The video ends with footage of the epic, orchestra-assisted performance and Jelly on his way out of town marveling at what just happened while re-watching the whole thing on his phone as he speeds to his next gig.

Watch Jelly Roll’s Eminem meet cute video below.

All products and services featured are independently chosen by editors. However, Billboard may receive a commission on orders placed through its retail links, and the retailer may receive certain auditable data for accounting purposes.

Billy Joel fans will get another chance to watch the Piano Man’s Madison Square Garden special, which will air on CBS on Friday (Aug. 23).

The special first aired in April 14 and re-aired on April 19 after a “network programming timing error” ended the initial broadcast early. CBS apologized for cutting the concert special short during its first airing, and announced that the special would re-air later that week.

“A network programming timing error ended last night’s Billy Joel special approximately two minutes early in the eastern and central time zones,” read the statement, which Joel posted on X at the time. “We apologize to Mr. Joel, his fans, our affiliated stations, and our audience whose viewing experience was interrupted during the last song. Due to the overwhelming demand from his legion of fans, BILLY JOEL: THE 100TH – LIVE AT MADISON SQUARE GARDEN will be rebroadcast in its entirety on CBS on April 19th at 9 p.m. ET/PT.”

More than 24 million viewers watched Joel’s Madison Square Garden special in April.

Read on for ways to watch and stream the concert special.

How to Watch Billy Joel’s Madison Square Garden Special

CBS will air an encore presentation of Billy Joel: The 100th — Live at Madison Square Garden on Friday at 9 p.m. ET/PT. The two-hour special, celebrating Joel’s 100th show at the famed venue, will also stream live on Paramount+ with Showtime.

No cable? You can watch CBS and other networks on DirecTV, Sling TV, and Fubo TV. Additionally, Paramount+ with Showtime includes live access to CBS.

DirecTV and Fubo offer free trials – a nice option if you don’t want to pay out of pocket. Plans start at $49.99 (regularly $79.99) for DirecTV Stream and $79.99 for Fubo. Both platforms include DVR recording and over 90 live channels, including sports and entertainment channels.

Sling TV’s streaming plans start at $20 for the first month to stream over 30 channels. Sling TV offers CBS in select regions.

Another free option: Paramount+ with Showtime is free for the first month and $12.99 per month, after the trial period ends. The platform combines Paramount+ and Showtime – which means double the streaming possibilities — and you have the option of streaming Paramount+ on Prime Video.

Joel closed out his Madison Square Garden residency in July. The “Piano Man” will perform in Cleveland on Sept. 13. Get tickets here.