Usher has won a court ruling allowing him to proceed with $700,000 legal claims against music producer Bryan-Michael Cox over a loan for a failed Atlanta restaurant.

A Monday (May 11) ruling in Fulton County court, first obtained and reported by Billboard, says Cox and his business partners cannot dismiss the lawsuit brought against them by the star (born Usher Raymond IV) this past November. This means the case will now move forward into evidence discovery and toward a possible trial.

Related

Cox, whose work with Usher and other R&B artists like Mariah Carey earned him a spot on Billboard’s top producers of the 21st century list, was part of a team that developed plans for a restaurant called “Homage ATL” in 2024. Cox’s business partners in the project were songwriter Keith Thomas, who’s also credited on multiple Usher hits, including the chart-topper “Love In This Club,” and Charles Hughes, who was previously involved in T.I.’s own troubled Atlanta restaurant.

Usher alleges these men approached him in 2024 about investing in the restaurant as a full partner and that he declined, instead opting to lend them $1.7 million to help fund the purchase of a $6 million building in Atlanta’s upscale Buckhead neighborhood. The real estate deal ultimately fell through, and Usher asked for his money back.

According to the lawsuit, the group’s attorney, Alcide Honoré, returned $1 million to Usher. But $700,000 is still missing — and the singer says Honoré effectively admitted that the funds had been improperly spent elsewhere. Now, Usher is leveling breach of contract claims against Cox, Thomas, Hughes and Honoré over the loan balance.

Cox and Thomas both argued that a judge should dismiss them from the case because Honoré was the sole person responsible for processing Usher’s loan, and they had no involvement in the movement of the funds. But Judge Craig L. Schwall Sr. denied the motion during a Monday hearing in Atlanta.

Related

“Construing the pleadings in plaintiff’s favor, those allegations are sufficient to survive dismissal at the pleading stage,” wrote the judge in his order. “Plaintiff has plausibly alleged that the moving defendants solicited, directed, benefited from, or retained the funds at issue, notwithstanding that the funds were routed through defendant Honoré’s attorney trust account.”

Hughes has not responded to the lawsuit. Honoré, meanwhile, countersued Usher last year for interfering with his reputation. Judge Schwall ruled Monday that this counterclaim “appears inartfully pled and may ultimately prove deficient as matter of law,” but he declined Usher’s request to dismiss it outright.

A lawyer for Thomas, Leron Rogers of the firm Fox Rothschild, told Billboard on Thursday (May 14) that they “respectfully disagree with the court’s ruling on procedural grounds.” According to Rogers, Judge Schwall made clear during Monday’s hearing that Honoré will be primarily responsible for explaining where Usher’s $700,000 has gone.

“Our client is aligned with the court’s primary question toward defendant Honoré concerning the location of Mr. Raymond’s money,” said Rogers. “We await attorney Honoré’s response.”

Lawyers representing Usher and the other defendants did not immediately return requests for comment. When the case was first filed, Cox wrote on Instagram that he was only a “passive minority shareholder” in Homage ATL: “I was not a participant in that business transaction and have no involvement in the ongoing legal process,” he claimed. “While I’m unable to share more details right now, I want to make one thing absolutely clear: my 27-year friendship with @usher remains fully intact.”


Billboard VIP Pass

A fashion brand called Chrome Hearts has dropped a trademark lawsuit it filed against Neil Young over his use of the same name for his new backing band.

The case, filed last year, took aim at The Chrome Hearts, Young’s new group that he debuted in 2024 and has played with ever since. It claimed that the name infringed the trademarks to a name the company had used since the late 1980s for apparel, jewelry and accessories.

Related

But in a court filing Thursday (May 14), Chrome Hearts said it would voluntarily dismiss the case against Young and the other members of the band. The filing did not indicate whether the case had ended in a settlement agreement or had simply been dropped.

Neither side immediately returned requests for comment.

For decades, Young toured and recorded off and on with the band Crazy Horse, often under the name Neil Young and Crazy Horse. In September 2024, he debuted The Chrome Hearts at FarmAid. The group released its debut album, Talkin to the Trees, in June 2025 and later went on a world tour.

The new name was apparently unwelcome news for Chrome Hearts, a Los Angeles-based brand that says it has sold apparel and other goods under that name — often written in a Gothic script with a stylized cross — since 1988.

“Defendants’ continued use of the confusingly similar [Neil Young & The Chrome Hearts] name in commerce violates Chrome Hearts’ valuable intellectual property rights,” the company wrote in its lawsuit against Young.

As Billboard wrote at the time, the case faced difficult odds in court. Trademark law doesn’t grant anyone an absolute monopoly on words, and it only protects brand names to the extent they’re used on similar goods or services in a way that confuses consumers. Would any fans really think Neil Young’s band was somehow linked to a small fashion brand?

Young, for his part, doesn’t appear to be backing away from the name. The Chrome Hearts is set to release a live album later this month, and recently finished recording the band’s second studio album — both under the full “Chrome Hearts” name.


Billboard VIP Pass

Coran Capshaw, founder of Red Light Management, will receive the lifetime music industry award at the T.J. Martell Foundation’s 51st annual New York Honors Gala on Tuesday, Sept. 15, at Cipriani 42nd Street in New York City.  The event is the foundation’s primary annual fundraiser.

Related

Capshaw has built Red Light into the world’s largest independent artist management company, where he personally manages Dave Matthews Band, Phish, Chris Stapleton and The Strokes, among others.  Beyond management, he has helped shape acclaimed music festivals and venues across the United States.

Capshaw is consistently ranked highly on the Billboard Power 100 List (he ranked No. 19 on the latest list, published in January). He also received an award for personal manager of the year at the 37th Annual Pollstar Awards last month in Los Angeles, as well as the City of Hope’s Spirit of Life Award in 2017. In 2011, he became the first artist manager to receive the Humanitarian Award at the Billboard Touring Awards.

“We are deeply honored to recognize our esteemed music industry colleague Coran Capshaw with this year’s Lifetime Music Industry Award, a tribute to decades of remarkable dedication and philanthropic leadership,” said Steve Gawley, executive vp of Republic Co/head of business & legal affairs at Republic Collective and chairman of the board of trustees at T.J. Martell Foundation. “Coran’s enduring commitment to philanthropy, as well as his ability to rally artists in support of meaningful causes, has made a profound impact on our community. We are proud to shine a spotlight on Coran’s exceptional leadership and lasting contributions to the causes that matter most.”

“I’m honored to support my longtime friend and colleague Coran Capshaw as he receives the T.J. Martell Foundation’s Lifetime Music Industry Award,” said Elliot Groffman, partner at Carroll Guido Groffman Cohen Bar & Karalian, LLP. “In all the years I’ve known Coran and worked alongside Red Light and their artists, philanthropy has always been close to his heart — particularly causes like T.J. Martell, which hits close to home for so many of us who’ve lost friends and colleagues to cancer.”

“I am incredibly honored to support this life-saving work,” Capshaw said in a statement. “Giving back has always been important to me, and being able to engage our generous music community to support vitally important organizations such as the T.J. Martell Foundation is something I’m proud of and will keep doing my part however I can.”

The event’s red carpet will be sponsored by Live Nation. The program will include special performances and celebrity presenters to be announced in the weeks ahead.

For more information on the T.J. Martell Foundation, visit their website. Click here to view tables, tickets, sponsorships and tribute journal ad opportunities.​


Billboard VIP Pass

The rise in AI-generated music has generated a lot of thoughts about the technology for Jack Antonoff.

The Bleachers frontman posted a note to fans via Instagram on Wednesday (May 13), ripping into so-called “musicians” who use artificial intelligence to create material. “What we do has become an ancient ritual,” Antonoff wrote. “You don’t have to write music anymore, you don’t have to record it and you don’t have to bring the band out and play it.”

Related

“And yet for us, the idea of optimizing what we do is a complete miss of the entire point of what compels us in the first place,” he continued on behalf of the traditional music community. “So to everyone who is gassed up about the new ways you can fake making art, by all means drive right off that cliff. We’re genuinely happy to see you go … godless whores.”

The Grammy-winning producer observed that, in his eyes, “It’s mainly the out of touch shouting about following this nightmare,” referencing people in entertainment who have championed adapting to the ways AI is threatening to change the industry. “The new artists I know are genuinely uninterested in anything that doesn’t come from within,” he added.

Antonoff is known for speaking out about issues in the music industry, becoming one of the most vocal stars in his opposition to the concert industry monopoly. “You and your band can’t turn a profit, and then we have to watch the companies that own all these rooms and monopolize the whole f—ing thing and post billions of earnings,” he said in conversation with Hayley Williams for Rolling Stone in October.

In recent weeks, he also made a joke at Ticketmaster’s expense after the entertainment behemoth posted about having successfully “caught” scalpers using its services. “You caught you?” he wrote on X in April.

See Antonoff’s post about AI in music below.


Billboard VIP Pass

Clarence Carter, the blues and soul musician and singer/songwriter with the raspy, emotional vocals whose hits included the sentimental “Patches” and the salacious “Strokin,’” has died at age 90.

Carter’s death was confirmed by Bill Carpenter, a spokesman for his former wife and fellow singer, Candi Staton. Carter died Wednesday of natural causes, according to Carpenter.

Related

Carter, a self-taught guitarist who was born blind in Montgomery, Alabama, and majored in music at Alabama State College, had his biggest hit in 1970 with “Patches,” a plaintive tale about a poor country boy who must become a man and run his family’s farm after his father dies that peaked at No. 4 on the Billboard Hot 100. His 1970 Patches album was also his highest-charting on the Billboard 200, peaking at No. 44.

But he specialized in exuberantly raunchy songs like “Strokin’,” a funky, talking ode to sex (“Have you ever made love just before breakfast?” he asks) that was too explicit for commercial radio but became a standard on nightclub jukeboxes and was featured in Eddie Murphy’s 1996 remake of The Nutty Professor.

Another favorite was “Making Love on the Dark End of the Street,” in which Carter narrates a long, cheerful account of how humans and other creatures will go to extremes in the pursuit of passion. His other songs about illicit love included “Slip Away,” a No. 6 Hot 100 hit in 1968, and “Back Door Santa.”

On his bluesy “The Road of Love,” Carter was backed by Duane Allman, then a little-known rocker and session musician who went on to cofound The Allman Brothers Band and make memorable contributions to records by Eric Clapton and Wilson Pickett among others. His hard-hitting “Tell Daddy” was the basis for an Etta James standard, “Tell Mama.”

Carter recorded some of his biggest hits at Fame Studios in Muscle Shoals, Alabama, where Pickett, Aretha Franklin and other soul greats recorded. In later years, he recorded for the now-defunct Ichiban Records and his own Cee Gee Entertainment.

Carter and Staton were married briefly the 1970s before they divorced. They had a son, Clarence Carter Jr.

In a 2012 interview with The Montgomery Advertiser, the elder Carter said, “I don’t know how much longer I’m going to be going, but I’m going to keep going until something tells me it’s time to quit or Old Man Death comes to run me down.”

–Additional reporting by Katie Atkinson

An Avicii wax figure was unveiled at the Las Vegas location of Madame Tussauds Wax Museum on Thursday (May 14).

The figure finds the producer in a way he’s best remembered by many: behind the decks wearing a flannel button-down shirt and backward baseball cap, right hand raised and a big smile on his face.

Related

An Avicii wax figure also debuted at the New York location of Madame Tussauds in 2019. In Las Vegas, the figure wears a different flannel button-down than in New York, swapping black-and-white for blue, red and black. (A representative for Madame Tussauds did not immediately respond to Billboard‘s request for comment on whether the New York figure is the same one that’s now in Las Vegas.)

See photos of the figure in its Las Vegas location below.

The Avicii figure is being unveiled in Las Vegas just ahead of EDC Las Vegas, which will draw upward of 200,000 dance music fans to the city for the three-day festival and the many adjacent parties happening on the Las Vegas Strip.

“Avicii truly embodies everything that the Las Vegas nightlife scene is known for,” Madame Tussauds Las Vegas GM Gabriel Hewitt says in a press release. “His new figure is a perfect fit for our location, and we can’t wait for guests to come see it.” This press release continues by saying that “The electric dance music icon’s figure will give guests the opportunity to relive Avicii’s stand out performances and pay tribute to his life.”

The New York figure was originally made in a collaboration between Madame Tussauds and the parents of the late artist. This past April 20 marked the eight-year anniversary of the producer’s death by suicide.

Avicii wax figure at Madame Tussaud's Las Vegas

Avicii wax figure at Madame Tussaud’s Las Vegas

Courtesy of Madame Tussauds

Avicii wax figure at Madame Tussaud's Las Vegas

Avicii wax figure at Madame Tussaud’s Las Vegas

Courtesy of Madame Tussauds

Avicii wax figure at Madame Tussaud's Las Vegas

Avicii wax figure at Madame Tussaud’s Las Vegas

Courtesy of Madame Tussauds

Madonna’s guerrilla marketing campaign for Confessions II continues, as an album track list has now been announced via posters that were plastered across major cities on Thursday (May 14).

The posters — which echo the album’s cover art — are the latest in the ongoing street marketing blitz for the project that began in mid-April. Since then, posters have appeared in major cities globally, teasing the album’s release date (July 3), title, visuals and cover art.

Related

On the new posters (of which Madonna’s official fan account MadonnaHQ reshared fan-snapped photos), 12 song titles are listed, divided into “Side 1” and “Side 2” with a notation of “33 1/3 RPM” — seemingly a nod to a vinyl album. Currently, there are two options of Confessions II available for preorder in a variety of configurations and variants – one with 12 tracks and one with 16 tracks.

Among the tracks revealed are the set’s lead single “Bring Your Love,” with Sabrina Carpenter, as well as “I Feel So Free,” which was the first song released from the project. Both tracks populate Billboard’s May 16-dated charts, including a Billboard Hot 100 debut for “Bring Your Love.”

Also among the announced tracks is “Danceteria,” which is titled after the famed former New York nightclub from the early 1980s that Madonna frequented pre-stardom and was pivotal in the launch of her career with Sire Records in 1982.

Confessions II is the sequel to Madonna’s 2005 Confessions on a Dance Floor album, which topped the Billboard 200 chart and went on to win the Grammy for best electronic/dance album. For Confessions II, Madonna reunited with her Confessions on a Dance Floor collaborator, writer/producer/DJ Stuart Price.

Also Thursday, Madonna was announced as a headliner for the 2026 World Cup final halftime show alongside Shakira and BTS, with the game taking place July 18, two weeks after her album’s July 3 release.

Here’s the track list that appears on the new poster:

Side 1
I Feel So Free
Good for the Soul
One Step Away
Bring Your Love
Danceteria
Read My Lips

Side 2
Everything
Love Without Words
Bizarre
School
Fragile
My Sins Are My Savior

Britney Spears is speaking out against reports that the pop star behaved in a concerning manner at a restaurant recently, calling them “ridiculous” and part of a larger “attack” on her character.

In a statement shared with People on Thursday (May 14), the spokesperson denied that Spears had done anything but enjoy “a quiet dinner with her assistant and bodyguard” on the night of the alleged incident. “She was simply telling the story about how her dog was barking at the neighbors,” they continued. “At no point did she put anyone in danger with a knife.”

Related

“She was cutting her hamburger in half,” the rep added. “This constant attack on everything that she does and this is exactly what happened 20 years ago when the media tried to depict Britney as a bad person. This is ridiculous and it needs to stop now.”

Billboard has reached out to Spears’ team for comment.

The rep’s response comes after a person on X claimed Wednesday (May 13) that they’d been seated that evening next to the hitmaker at a restaurant, writing that “one diner feared for her life” because of Spears’ alleged behavior. “An INSANE dining experience,” the person added in the post, which made the rounds on social media. “This is not a joke…”

The following day, TMZ reported that Spears had allegedly started “screaming” and “barking” while out to eat at Blue Dog Tavern in Sherman Oaks, Calif., adding that one witness had claimed the singer walked past their table with a knife in hand.

Spears is currently in the process of moving forward after her arrest for suspicion of a DUI in Ventura County, Calif., in March, shortly after which she checked herself into a treatment facility. A few weeks prior to the restaurant reports, she took a plea deal and was sentenced to a year of probation, having accepted guilt for a misdemeanor charge known as a “wet reckless” — something less severe than the more serious charge of driving under the influence of drugs and alcohol.

At the time, her attorney, Michael Goldstein, said that Spears’ guilty plea shows she “has accepted responsibility for her conduct.”

“She has taken significant steps to implement positive change which is clearly reflected in the Ventura County District Attorney’s decision to reduce the charge in this case and dismiss the DUI,” he continued. “Britney appreciates this discretion and is also grateful for the outpouring of support she has received.”


Billboard VIP Pass

DJ charity soccer tournament Copa Del Rave has been a fixture in Los Angeles since it launched in 2019. Now, the tournament is activating in a big way for the 2026 FIFA World Cup that starts in June.

In conjunction with the tournament — being played in 16 cities throughout the United States, Mexico and Canada — Copa Del Rave will set up in Los Angeles nightclubs Academy and Exchange L.A. for a residency of match viewing parties.

Each event will feature DJs, labels and party brands representing the countries playing in that day’s match, with Claude VonStroke repping Team USA, Tokimonsta’s Young Art label showing up for South Korea, Reggaeton Rave, Gasolina and Bolo’s Vibraza Records locking in for Mexico and Blaq Pages and Afrobeats To The World repping the African diaspora. The dancefloors will be going off both before and after each game. See the full lineup below.

These events are free with RSVP, with VIP tables also available for a fee. Secure your spot and see the complete event schedule here.

Copa del Rave has raised more than $75,000 for various charities since 2019. Proceeds from this year’s event will go to Common Goal, an organization that creates greater access for kids to play soccer.

“Copa del Rave has always been a huge labor of love, and we’re grateful for everyone’s support over the years,” Copa del Rave co-founders Alastair Duncan and Jonathan McDonald tell Billboard in a joint statement. “For the stars to align, and us to be able to platform global dance music and DJ culture, and support a good cause alongside the world’s biggest sporting event here in LA, was a dream opportunity. Massive thanks to all the DJs and partners, and to the venue team at Academy, for helping bring the Residency to life. It’s going to be a really fun few weeks.”

Meanwhile, stars from all genres are getting in the game for World Cup festivities, with Madonna, Shakira and BTS announced as headliners for the FIFA World Cup Hafltime show happening at MetLife Stadium on July 19. This will mark the first time the World Cup has ever featured a halftime show.

Copa del Rave 2026 Lineup

Copa del Rave 2026 Lineup

Courtesy of Copa del Rave

Geoff Emerick was just a teenager in June 1962, employed as an apprentice sound engineer at EMI Studios (later renamed Abbey Road), when a then-little-known English rock band recorded a demo in the studio.

John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison and drummer Pete Best laid down four tracks that day — “Bésame Mucho,” “Love Me Do,” “PS, I Love You,” and “Ask Me Why” — on a magnetic recording tape, which was then shuttled over to record producer George Martin at EMI’s headquarters on Manchester Square.

Related

You know the rest: After ditching Best for Ringo Starr, The Beatles broke out with “Love Me Do,” launched Beatlemania, and became the most famous band of all time. Emerick rose with them, serving as chief engineer on iconic records like Abbey Road and becoming what Variety once called the “behind-the-scenes brains that helped shape the Beatles sound.”

But here’s what you probably don’t know: Emerick held onto that demo tape, which had been sent to a nearby squash court where “tapes went to die.” He kept it in his possession for decades, all the way until his 2018 death, when it was discovered among his things. And now, six decades after it was first recorded, Universal Music Group (UMG) wants it back.

In a legal battle quietly raging in Los Angeles court, both the music giant and Emerick’s estate are asking a judge to rule them the rightful owner of the tape, which UMG has called the “first known Beatles recording.” The estate’s lawyers say it was essentially thrown away, and that only Emerick saved it from destruction. UMG’s attorneys say it was always company property — and that it wasn’t his to save.

“At issue in this action,” the company’s lawyers wrote in recent court filings, “is a highly valuable artifact of rock and roll history that was stolen.”

——————–

Emerick was only 16 when he applied for a job at Abbey Road, apparently at the suggestion of a school guidance counselor. When he got the position, it came with a robust salary of about $8 a week: “Any disappointment I had in the low wages was more than offset by my elation at landing the position,” he recalled in his 2006 memoir. “At long last, I was in.”

Related

For Beatles obsessives and audio junkies, the rest of Emerick’s career is well-known. He worked for several years under Norman Smith, the lead engineer on the Beatles’ early albums up until Rubber Soul. He then took over the top job in 1966 at Martin’s request, starting with the technologically innovative Revolver: “It was implanted when we started Revolver that every instrument should sound unlike itself,” Emerick once reportedly said.

For most of the band’s remaining years, Emerick was at the helm with Martin in the booth, perhaps most notably on the psychedelic, sound-effect-laden Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, for which he later won a Grammy. The notable exceptions were the White Album, which he quit mid-recording session over the tortuous process of creating “Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da,” and the subsequent Let It Be. But he later returned for the band’s final session that yielded Abbey Road, then spent decades working with McCartney and other stars, including Elvis Costello and Supertramp.

“Geoff Emerick allowed the Beatles to break rules at Abbey Road, and to develop their penchant for new ways to record,” Bob Spitz, the author of The Beatles: The Biography, tells Billboard. “He also was the Beatles’ age. He was one of them as opposed to one of the suits, and that made him an important figure. He related to the band, and they trusted him.”

When Emerick passed away suddenly of a heart attack in 2018 at the age of 72, Martin’s son called him one of the “finest and most innovative engineers to have graced a recording studio.” McCartney himself eulogized him as someone who had been “always open to the many new ideas that we threw at him” during the later Beatles albums: “I’ll always remember him with great fondness, and I know his work will be long remembered by connoisseurs of sound.”

Because he died without a will, spouse or children, Emerick’s case was sent to probate court — a legal process designed to sort out the affairs of people without clear estate planning (the same thing that befell Prince‘s estate after his 2016 death). A Los Angeles judge eventually named a group of Emerick’s cousins as his heirs and appointed an administrator, Maya Rubin, to figure out what they’d inherit.

Related

While searching through his Laurel Canyon house, Rubin and others came upon that 1962 demo. “The master tape is significant as an artifact of early Beatles recordings,” she wrote in a 2019 court filing. “[It] was recorded in June 1962 and features the Beatles’ original drummer, Peter Best, rather than Ringo Starr.”

UUMG, which had acquired EMI in 2012, quickly found out about it. In their own court filings, the label’s lawyers said the company had been alerted to the tape’s existence when it was listed online for sale to “the highest bidder” just weeks after Emerick’s death. The company said it had reached out and “demanded its return,” apparently unsuccessfully.

The tape was no small find. While it’s hard to exactly confirm the claim that it’s the first known Beatles recording — earlier recordings exist of McCartney-Lennon-Harrison as The Quarrymen, as do copies of the famed Decca audition — it’s certainly a cultural talisman of the highest order. The June 6 session was their first at Abbey Road and plays a key part in the historiography of the period just before the Beatles became world-famous.

“When you have a band that’s as big as The Beatles, every little snippet that they made is historic and something to be treasured,” says Spitz.

With ownership of that object disputed, both sides filed formal petitions in probate court, asking the judge to confirm them as the owner. And so the battle was on.

——————-

It seems Emerick wasn’t actually present at the now-fateful June 1962 session. In his memoir, he recounts his first run-in with the Beatles as taking place at a later 1962 recording session that featured Starr, not Best, on the drums. The estate says in court filings that Emerick was “not at the test recording session”; UMG says he was “employed at EMI during the recording.”

Related

But both sides agree that he was there two years later, in 1964, when fellow EMI engineer Ken Scott alerted him about the existence of the Beatles demo tape. Scott noticed that the tape had been left in a nearby squash court — a spot located across the street from Abbey Road that EMI had started using in the mid-1950s to store old tapes. So Emerick went to the squash court, found the tape, and took it.

That’s where the agreement stops. In its legal filings, Emerick’s estate argues the court was essentially a garbage dump — a place where “tapes went to die” — and that by sending it there, EMI had legally abandoned ownership of it. The estate says Scott had been specifically sent there to “dispose of such discarded tapes in the rubbish,” but that he instead “put them aside and told Emerick.”

The estate says Emerick aimed only to “rescue” the tape from destruction, and that it “would not exist today” if not for him: “[UMG] intentionally abandoned ownership of the master tape and box by sending them across the street to the squash court to be discarded with similarly abandoned property.”

UMG sees things differently. It says the squash court was still company-controlled property, and that a tape sent there was not abandoned but merely “no longer a work in progress.” Ken Townsend, another legendary Abbey Road engineer, gave a sworn statement that it had been strictly against the rules to remove tapes from the court: “If you were employed by a company, you didn’t steal their goods,” he said.

UMG’s lawyers argue the old tapes were not free for the taking, regardless of whether they were marked for destruction. “It is obvious that when a recording artist or studio discards an unwanted recording, he or she does not actually mean to ‘abandon’ it to the public domain,” they write. “A novelist who throws away pages from a handwritten first draft of a story cannot possibly intend that a trash-picker can acquire ownership of the draft and publish it himself.”

Related

The case gets more complicated from there. The estate also argues UMG’s claim to the tape is barred by the statute of limitations, which it says lapsed six years after the tape left the studio. UMG says that’s not true — that Emerick fraudulently took the demo and then lied about it, including when directly asked about it as EMI was assembling materials for the 1990s Beatles Anthology albums.

The final disputed issue involves paperwork. The estate argues UMG cannot show a “chain of title” that proves it is even the rightful legal successor to Abbey Road, and thus lacks standing to demand the return of the tape in the first place. UMG, meanwhile, says that issue was settled long ago and is obviously incorrect.

After a key court hearing earlier this month, the two sides are now finally headed for a showdown. First, they’ll submit briefs to the judge on key issues in the case, then head to trial early next year if the dispute is still not resolved.

In a statement to Billboard, the estate’s lead attorney, Kenneth D. Freundlich, says Emerick preserved an artifact that had been “destined for destruction” and had never hidden it from anyone over the subsequent decades. He says UMG is now, years later, unfairly asking a court to “brand one of the most respected recording engineers in music history a thief.”

“The corporation that was throwing this tape in the garbage in 1964 does not get to rewrite history 60 years later,” Freundlich says. “Geoff Emerick saved this piece of music history, and Ms. Rubin’s obligation is to gather and protect the property of Mr. Emerick’s estate, and she will vigorously resist any effort to besmirch his reputation or diminish his legacy.”

A spokesman for UMG declined to comment on the dispute.

——————–

The unspoken question hanging over the case is what each side intends to do with the tape. Does the estate plan to sell it off and split the money among Emerick’s heirs? Does UMG plan to release these decades-old recordings to a fandom eager for any unheard Beatles material?

Related

On that one, the answer doesn’t actually seem to depend on the outcome of the case. In court filings, the estate explicitly acknowledges that it has no rights to the music itself and that UMG owns the copyrights to the songs. Freundlich says the estate has already handed over digital copies to UMG, meaning the label could theoretically release the songs without recovering the physical tape.

Neither side would comment on their plans if they win the case. But one thing is clear: That tape is worth a lot of money.

Back in 2015, The Beatles’ first-ever contract with manager Brian Epstein was sold at auction for more than $550,000. A few years prior, a handwritten sheet of lyrics to “A Day in the Life” sold for $1.2 million at Sotheby’s. The band’s instruments have repeatedly sold for far more than that.

The most direct comps are perhaps a bit lower. In 2016, a 10-inch acetate record from 1962, the first known Beatles disc to be cut, sold at auction for $110,000. But Elvis Presley’s first recording, a 1953 acetate, went for $300,000 in 2015.

For Beatles experts like Spitz, regardless of the actual price, such a find is “invaluable” from a historical perspective. “It’s like finding another original copy of the Constitution,” he says with a laugh. “It’s like the Shroud of Turin.”

“It’s a part of Beatles history,” Spitz continues. “And that Beatles history is one of the most valuable parts of rock and roll history.”


Billboard VIP Pass