Initially, Durand Bernarr thought Bilal won the Grammy.

Related

But first, he had to let Jimmy Jam get past the first syllable of whatever was written on the card in his hand. By the time the famed producer finished announcing “BLOOM, Durand Bernarr” as the winner of best progressive R&B album, the virtuosic, Cleveland-bred vocalist was halfway through a mad dash to the stage — in a Luar Jehan mule, no less — to deliver an instantly viral and endlessly memed acceptance speech for his first career Grammy.

“It completely slipped my mind where I put my speech. As I’m running up, I’m like, ‘Oh my goodness, let me get my notes app’ —  and my publicist is running behind me with it,” he says with a laugh while catching up with Billboard. “People thought I was changing my bio to ‘Grammy Award-winning,’ they said I was texting somebody — but I was just trying to get that speech, because you only have 45 seconds!”

And in those 45 seconds (and then some), his charisma proved inescapable. The New York Times named his triumph as one of “seven great Grammy winners you didn’t hear on T.V.”; Essence profiled his stylist, Vincent Smith, to break down his winning look and Them proclaimed that his acceptance speech was “a burst of Black queer joy.” Grammy-winning songwriter James Fauntleroy wrote on X that he’s “never seen the whole community collectively celebrate a Grammy win” like Bernarr’s, and fellow nominee Destin Conrad took to Instagram Stories, writing “Black gay boys taking it b—h, I don’t give a f—k!” Kendrick Lamar even stopped to dap him up on his way to accepting best rap album for GNX, the first award of the telecast. In contrast, Bernarr hosted an intimate celebration with close friends — his earnest attempt to “be as present as possible.”

The day after his speech (Feb. 2), Bernarr’s catalog exploded 546% in weekly official on-demand U.S. streams, according to Luminate, despite his triumph happening hours before the telecast. It’s fitting that Durand finally took home his first Grammy (he boasts four career nods) on the first day of Black History Month (Feb. 1), 100 years after it originated as Negro History Week and 50 years after President Ford officially recognized the celebration. His win was a triumph for churchy, queer Black folk everywhere, the exact intersection of identity whose art is constantly pillaged and repackaged, while their individual persons are often discarded and ignored.

“We have worked!” he says emphatically. “Yes, we’re excited! What is there to play cool about? We’ve been acknowledged for our hard work!”

Born to a music teacher mother and an audio engineer father, Bernarr entered the music industry at just 16 years old, accompanying his dad as a production assistant for an Earth, Wind & Fire tour. As he cut his teeth professionally, Bernarr used the ever-waning power of third spaces to hone his musical and vocal chops: He attended the Cleveland Institute of Music, dabbled in acting at Playhouse Square, mounted stage productions at Karamu House Theatre, and even frequented open mic nights and poetry slams.

Of course, he owes his sanctified grounding and gospel-informed musical foundation to the hours he spent hooting and hollering in the church choir. His impassioned renditions of gospel standards like “Total Praise” and “Calvary” helped him accrue an online following when he first started sharing clips on YouTube (“Holy Commentating” remains a classic) — and they were the first posts to resurge following his Grammy win.

“I honestly could not imagine my personality or sense of humor without Black church culture,” he says. “It’s such a big part of how I express myself. It’s important we acknowledge our roots, whether that’s sonically or how we move in our character. “

Bernarr’s early YouTube blueprint harnesses the same energy he tapped into on BLOOM a decade and a half later: an inimitable balance of the sacred and the secular, as well as the comedy and theatricality woven through both spheres. A debut mixtape (Alcoholharmony) arrived in 2009, which gave way to a 2010 EP of Erykah Badu covers that helped him land an ongoing gig as one of her background vocalists. And to be clear, a Grammy win isn’t stopping him from fulfilling his BGV duties. “Who else gon’ be tenor?” he quips. “I want to continue being of service; it’s not a competition to me. It’s not an ego thing. I enjoy [singing backup] because I genuinely love what I do.”

His contributions as a background vocalist and songwriter for projects by artists ranging from Kaytranada to The Internet brought him closer to Grammy glory throughout the 2010s, but his first nomination would come in 2025 for En Route, an EP that competed for best progressive R&B album. The following year, he emerged as the second-most nominated artist in the R&B field, with three nods for BLOOM and its tracks. At its core, BLOOM — which arrived almost exactly a year ago — is about friendship, a relatively underexplored subject in contemporary R&B. Across 15 shape-shifting tracks, featuring appearances by T-Pain and GAWD, Bernarr cartwheels through funk-driven soul, Prince-esque rock balladry, and ‘00s pop&B with remarkable precision.

Not only is the album a clear culmination of his primary influences, but it’s also a testament to the power of collaboration. It’s why Bernarr began his acceptance speech by reminding the crowd, “We are all we got — and we know who I am referring to.” After penning most of his catalog solo, Bernarr opened his creative process to additional songwriters like “Freaky Rob” Gueringer, resulting in both his most expansive album yet, and deeper ties with the artist community that would eventually get him to that Grammy stage.

“Durand’s voice is otherworldly, and he writes very specific to him, and that’s gotten us to this point,” explains his publicist and BLOOM co-executive producer Shean England. “But how do we continue to elevate your sound and creativity? By bringing in artists he’s actually friends with, and people he’s been wanting to work with. It was really a community project, and Durand is an extension of that. He calls his fanbase his “cousins,” because it really is a family affair.”

Though she does not appear on BLOOM, Avery Sunshine, the 2025 best progressive R&B album Grammy winner (So Glad to Know You), proved to be a key member of this family. And it was at her urging that Bernarr even wrote an acceptance speech. “I think it was the tone behind it,” he reflects. “It was this feeling of, ‘I counted myself out, or I got counted out, and I wish I would have given myself the consideration to be prepared.’”

Beyond that encouragement, the two independent artists also sat for a 45-minute, in-depth conversation about their musical journeys. Couple that with ensuring Bernarr performed essentially everywhere he could, and you have the two primary tenets of England’s victorious Grammy campaign. From a hilarious viral clip of him belting out “Do you know the Muffin Man?” to the eternal life of early breakthrough hit “Mango Butter,” Team Bernarr took advantage of every click-worthy moment and turned that attention back to BLOOM.

“We won because I wasn’t trying to do everything by myself,” Bernarr says. “And now I say, if I don’t have to do it by myself, I don’t want to do it by myself. Creating is a playground; when you have company that has just as big an imagination as you, it makes the experience more fulfilling.”

And so, Bernarr handwrote a speech. In fact, that’s what England was clutching in his hand as he sprinted down the aisle behind him. While his delivery instantly made the speech memorable, it’s the content that made it so immediately resonant for so many viewers. Here was an openly queer, flamboyant, sanctified Black man accepting music’s highest honor with both of his parents standing behind him. Here was a self-proclaimed “butch queen” being honored for an album about friendship in a genre that generally prefers to ponder romantic love and sex.

“A point had to be made, and a standard had to be set,” Bernarr says, taking care to stress every syllable. “I felt that it was important for people to see that not all of us are coming from certain experiences. There are those of us [who] have active fathers in our lives who allow us to be ourselves. That is a healing component that was needed in this time; now I’m inspiring fathers to take inventory on how they are handling their children and loved ones. How your children treat you when you’re an adult, and you don’t need them, is your report card. This was me showing the world what an outstanding job [my parents] have done.”

The same night Bernarr triumphed, Leon Thomas took home his first two Grammys for his own music, and the late D’Angelo and Richard Smallwood were honored with an all-star, Ms. Lauryn Hill-led tribute. The legacy of Black male vocalists towered over the ceremony, and that wasn’t lost on Bernarr, despite his personal win.

“When you’re in the moment, it’s about you, but afterwards, it’s beyond you,” he reflects. “I’m standing on the shoulders of those men. And I’m glad that they not only crawled but trudged through times when it wasn’t okay to be too much of yourself. As loud and boisterous as Little Richard was, there was still this element of not fully loving yourself. I like to think that I’m a continuation of that, but in a way that is genuinely being embraced and celebrated.

“We are both Black gay men, living a dream in a world that tries to show us that we can’t or try to take it, take it away from us,” adds England, who joined forces with Bernarr in November 2021 after stints at entertainment companies like Beyoncé’s Parkwood. “That’s not something that people can just take away because they didn’t give it to us.”

It’s been over two weeks since the Grammys, and Bernarr is still wading through congratulations messages. Notably, some are from potential new besties like Tyla — who hit him up with, “Chile, just from the run alone, shoot, I want to be friends,” after his speech. A deluxe version of Bloom is in the works, as are forthcoming collaborations with Vic Mensa, Dawn Richard, and Sebastian Mikael.

Meanwhile, he’s set to combine his musical and comedic chops into a special variety show at Netflix Is a Joke on May 7; the week prior, he’ll play two sold-out shows at the newly opened Blue Note Jazz Club in Los Angeles on April 29. He also auditioned for the role of James “Thunder” Early in Dreamgirls, which makes its Broadway return this fall, but his You Gon’ Grown, Too Tour conflicted with callbacks. As a newly minted Grammy winner, the opportunities are endless, so England’s top priority is maintaining a pace that respects Bernarr’s health while keeping up with this “huge momentous period that has changed [their] lives.”

“My dream show is my own show — a combination between the Chappelle Show and That’s So Raven,” Bernarr muses as his Uber pulls up to the set of The Jennifer Hudson Show, which he’ll be appearing on later that day. “The idea that I have hasn’t been done. But being an independent artist who has done the things that I’ve done while being who I am ain’t never happened either.”

Swedish singer-songwriter Lykke Li signed with Neon Gold Records/Futures for the release of her sixth studio album, The Afterparty, which is set for release on May 8. The first single from the album, “Lucky Again,” dropped on Feb. 12.

“I was twirling around in love addiction for [my previous] albums,” said Lykke Li in a statement on The Afterparty. “Now I’m going into my existential era.”

She added, “I find that we’re in an era where everyone is talking about, ‘My higher self’, F–k that. This is an album dealing with your lower self: your need for revenge, your shame, despair, all of it.”

Related

According to a press release, The Afterparty was written in Los Angeles and recorded in Stockholm with “a 17-piece string orchestra, maximalist arrangements, ‘apocalyptic bongos,’ and a whole lot of flute.”

Of “Lucky Again,” Li said, “To me it’s samsara in a song. The wheel of life; winning, losing, living, dying. Having had something and praying you’ll have it again. Whether it’s sex, money, vitality, love. I always said I wanted the Vivaldi song at my wedding or funeral but I think this is giving more revenge heist energy.” (Listen to “Lucky Again” here.)

Ahead of the album’s release, Li is set to perform at this year’s Coachella, followed by a string of live dates through the summer. Her previous albums include Youth Novels, Wounded Rhymes, I Never Learn, So Sad So Sexy and EYEEYE.

Check out the rest of the latest artist signings below.

This week, in its 20th frame on the Billboard Hot 100, Taylor Swift‘s “Opalite” jumps from from No. 8 to No. 1. The hit song, which originally debuted at No. 2 on the Hot 100 dated Oct. 18, 2025 (following the release of parent album The Life of a Showgirl) was boosted by a surge in song sales, with new physical editions of it shipping out to fans, and new remixes of it being made available for digital purchase and streaming.

With its ascent to pole position, the song becomes the second Showgirl single to top the Hot 100 — following “The Fate of Ophelia,” which debuted at No. 1 and ruled for a total of 10 weeks (Swift’s personal best) between 2025-26. That makes Showgirl just the second-ever Swift album to boast multiple Hot 100 leaders, following 2014’s 1989, which topped the chart with three singles: “Shake It Off,” “Blank Space” and the Kendrick Lamar-featuring “Bad Blood.”

With her second album featuring multiple Hot 100 No. 1s, Swift joins an exclusive club of artists with two or more albums that boast two or more No. 1 hits on their tracklist. In fact, in the nearly 68-year history of the Hot 100, Swift becomes just the 22nd artist who can make such a claim — with the full list excluding such all-time Hot 100 heavy-hitters as Madonna (who scored 12 No. 1s, but only included multiple such hits on the same original album once, with 1986’s True Blue) and Elton John (who scored nine No. 1s, but, surprisingly, never with multiple leaders on the same album).

Below, find the complete list of artists who have pulled off this chart feat, starting with the two artists who have done it the most times — who, not coincidentally, also happen to be the two artists with the most No. 1s in Hot 100 history.

(For the purposes of this list, we only counted songs towards an album’s tally that appeared on the original tracklist in some version, and had never previously appeared on an official album release by that artist — so songs later added to deluxe reissues were not included towards the tallies of their original albums, nor were songs that appeared on the original album counted towards the deluxe version. In the case where artists released different versions of an album or different albums altogether for different markets, we went with the U.S.-released albums and their corresponding tracklists.

We did not count various artist soundtracks for this list — and did not consider prior inclusion on such a soundtrack before appearing on an artist’s original album as disqualifying to counting towards that album’s tally. We also did not count compilation albums unless they consisted of a majority of material that was either previously unreleased, or released within the period following the lead artist’s most recent full-length effort.)

Billboard VIP Pass

THE BIG STORY: Two years after the Department of Justice filed a sweeping antitrust lawsuit against Live Nation seeking to split the company from Ticketmaster, a federal judge ruled that the case could move ahead to a blockbuster trial.

The feds claim Live Nation runs an illegal “flywheel” — reaping revenue from ticket buyers, using that money to sign artists, then leveraging that repertoire to lock venues into exclusive ticketing contracts that yield ever more revenue.

Related

After more than a year of discovery, Live Nation urged the judge to end that case, arguing that little hard evidence had been uncovered. But in his ruling last week, Judge Arun Subramanian (yes, that Arun Subramanian) said the government could proceed to trial on several key accusations, including that Live Nation abused its vast portfolio of amphitheaters to force artists to use its promotion services.

“A reasonable jury could certainly find that artists were coerced into going with Live Nation as their promoter to get into its amphitheaters,” the judge wrote.

For more, go read our full story here, with the judge’s actual written ruling; Live Nation’s unusual response urging the feds to settle; and its push for a trial postponement amid a fast-track appeal. And stay with Billboard for the trial – set to start next Monday.

You’re reading The Legal Beat, a weekly newsletter about music law from Billboard Pro, offering you a one-stop cheat sheet of big new cases, important rulings and all the fun stuff in between. To get the newsletter in your inbox every Tuesday, subscribe here.

Other top stories this week…

-Two producers who dropped their lawsuit against Karol G over a song from her chart-topping album Mañana Será Bonito – and, in a rare move, apologized for filing it in the first place.

-The record labels are cracking down on corporate social media accounts that use popular songs. Here’s why it’s happening, and what experts say might come next.

-Skaters at the 2026 Winter Olympics got a hard lesson in the complex world of music licensing as they tried to use popular songs in their routines: “It’s a clearance nightmare.”

-Prosecutors filed their main brief in Sean “Diddy“ Combs’ criminal appeal, arguing there’s no basis to disturb the mogul’s prostitution conviction and four-year prison sentence.

Related

-Miley Cyrus asked a judge to dismiss the long-running lawsuit claiming her chart-topping “Flowers” ripped off Bruno Mars’ “When I Was Your Man,” arguing the two songs are “very different.”

-As Lil Durk’s murder-for-hire trial nears, a judge ruled that prosecutors can introduce some of his lyrics as evidence, ruling they are directly relevant to the accusations in the case.

-OutKast reached a settlement to end a lawsuit against an electronic dance music duo calling itself ATLiens – the same name as one of the hip hop duo’s best-known songs.

-Regional Mexican music legend Ramón Ayala is facing a $25 million lawsuit from a tour photographer alleging Ayala’s son engaged in abusive behavior toward the staffer.

-R&B singer Kenny Lattimore filed a lawsuit against distributor SRG/ILS Group, claiming he’s received only a single royalty check since the release of his last album in 2021.

Related

-In unrelated Live Nation news, a judge refused to dismiss a civil suit over the deadly 2023 shooting at the Beyond Wonderland festival at Washington’s Gorge Amphitheatre.

-Donny Osmond is facing a lawsuit from a concertgoer who says she suffered a “traumatic retinal injury” after being hit with a giant inflatable lit-up ball at his Las Vegas residency.

-The estate of Isaac Hayes reached a settlement with President Donald Trump to end copyright litigation over the use of the 1966 song “Hold On, I’m Comin’” at election rallies.

Dearest gentle reader: More stunning covers of hit songs are set to arrive when part two of Bridgerton season four debuts on Netflix Thursday (Feb. 26), and Billboard can exclusively reveal the songs that will soundtrack the conclusion of the Cinderella-inspired love story between Benedict Bridgerton (Luke Thompson) and Sophie Baek (Yerin Ha).

Episode 405 kicks off the second half of the season with not one, not two, but three covers: Charli xcx‘s Brat track “360,” which peaked at No. 41 on the Billboard Hot 100 in August 2024, done by Peter Gregson; Billie Eilish‘s Hit Me Hard and Soft hit “Birds of a Feather” (No. 2 in October 2024) by Gemini Strings; and Teddy Swims‘ No. 1 hit “Lose Control” by Vitamin String Quartet.

The next episode goes a little retro, with covers of The Cars’ 1978 hit “Just What I Needed” (No. 27) and Sting’s “Fields of Gold” (No. 23 in 1993) by Altum Quartet and Music Lab Collective, respectively.

The covers skip an episode to focus on the score by composer Kris Bowers, but return with episode 408, aka the season finale. It will feature covers of Camila Cabello’s Hot 100 No. 6 hit “Never Be the Same” and Lord Huron’s “The Night We Met” (No. 84) by Strings From Paris and Joni Fuller, respectively.

The full soundtrack for part two will be available via Capitol Records on streaming services the same day the final four episodes arrive on Netflix.

“We’re always looking for songs that can match the emotions our characters are experiencing and moments that can best accentuate and enhance those feelings for the audience as our characters go through their arcs this season,” Justin Kamps, Bridgerton‘s music supervisor, tells Billboard. “There was definitely an emphasis on the masquerade in the season four premiere with three songs there and then pieces throughout the season that echo back to it like [Taylor Swift’s] ‘Enchanted’ [in episode 402] and ‘The Night We Met.’ There’s also an element of, these people want to be together, but society will not allow it, and that’s reflected in songs like [Olivia Rodrigo’s] ‘Bad Idea Right?’ [in episode 404] and ‘Lose Control.’”

As for how the hit songs the show takes for the second part of season four, Kamps gushes that they’re “wonderful,” but one sticks out to him in particular — Gregson’s take on “360.”

“It’s such an honor to have someone of his talent arrange a cover for us this season, and his cover of ‘360’ is just so fun,” he says. “Part two is extra special because all but one of the covers are premiering first in the show, so fans won’t have a chance to hear them ahead of time and get to discover them organically along with everyone else when the episodes drop on the 26th. There are some absolutely gorgeous ones awaiting fans. I’m looking at you, ‘Never Be the Same’ and ‘The Night We Met.’ I love the covers in part two — I can’t say that enough.”

Alexandra Patsavas, Netflix’s senior director of music, series, also feels strongly about the hits featured in Bridgerton. “Our primary goal has always been for the music to act as the heartbeat of the series, crafting something truly special by reimagining songs that fans know and love,” she tells Billboard. “This approach has done more than just serve the story; Bridgerton has significantly impacted culture by bridging the gap between classical and pop music, popularizing string-quartet covers of modern hits. … The real magic of an instrumental cover is that it’s subliminal — you hear the lyrics even if you don’t hear them out loud.”

Experience Bridgerton‘s latest orchestral covers when part two of season four drops on Netflix Feb. 26.


Billboard VIP Pass

David Ahumada has been appointed head of CAN LATAM at ONE Publishing.

With more than 10 years of experience in the publishing industry, Ahumada, a Colombian music executive, will consolidate operations in the Andean region and accelerate regional growth aligned with ONE Publishing’s global vision. His new role will focus on active catalog development, regional partnerships creations and the optimization of services. 

Related

Additional priorities include strengthening relationships with songwriters, fostering regional co-creation initiatives, and reinforcing partnerships with collective management organizations and key industry stakeholders.

“Borderless co-creation, sharing audiences, genres, and cultures, at a time when LATAM is at the center of global attention, is extraordinary,” Ahumada said in a press statement. “I am excited about ONE Publishing’s commitment to technology as a facilitator of a less visible side of the business, publishing, making it more accessible, fair, and efficient for creators. That path represents the future, and being part of it means staying at the forefront, strengthening service to songwriters, and generating more opportunities for art.”

Prior to being named ONE Publishing’s head of CAN LATAM, Ahumada built his career as an A&R at Warner Music Group, Warner Chappell Music and Sony Music Publishing. Also with a background in music business and audio engineering, he will bring creative sensibility, editorial judgment and a data-driven mindset to the team. 

With the new appointment, ONE Publishing not only deepens its positioning in the Latin American region, but it also “reinforces its growth strategy built on innovation, creative development, and an active defense of authors’ rights as the foundation of its publishing business in Latin America,” as noted in the statement. 

“The Older I Get” singer Bryan Andrews has signed with WME for global representation across all areas.

Andrews has earned over 1.2 million Instagram followers and 3.6 million TikTok followers, as “The Older I Get” topped Billboard’s Country Digital Song Sales and Digital Song Sales charts, while Andrews topped the Emerging Artists chart.

The Missouri native worked as a pipe welder for over four years while pursuing music. Over the past year, Andrews has gained attention online not only for his traditional country-leaning sound, but also for regularly and boldly discussing his political beliefs on social media, and in the process defying stereotypes of country music entertainers.

Andrews was recently signed to Sony/Disruptor Records, and is managed by 10 and 8 Management’s Nicholas Mishko. His new song, “Are We Great Yet?” will be released March 6.

“I’m truly honored to be part of the WME roster. I’m thankful for the chance to tell my story with a team that shares my belief that history will be told through art,” Andrews said in a statement. “There’s no one else I’d rather tell it with.”

“Bryan has built an undeniable movement, and the growth we are seeing is extraordinary and backed by conviction and connection,” added WME’s Nate Towne. “We are excited to grow his live business globally and help create the right opportunities as his career enters this next phase,” adds WME’s Carrie Murphy. WME’s Abby Wells Baas summed it up with, “Bryan is one of those rare artists whose live show doesn’t just entertain, it converts.”

Lenny Kravitz, Maroon 5, Ozuna and Yandel are among the artists who will headline the Starlite Occident Marbella 2026 lineup, the festival announced on Tuesday (Feb. 24).

Related

The two-month “boutique” festival, which celebrates its 15th anniversary this year, also has Grupo Frontera, Manuel Turizo, Danny Ocean, Carlos Rivera, Gente de Zona, Mau y Ricky and Elvis Crespo among its first confirmed artists, along with Deep Purple, Delaossa, Sergio Dalma, Zucchero, Diana Krall, and more.

Held every summer in a natural outdoor quarry in Marbella, Spain, Starlite Occident Marbella brings together rock, pop, Latin music, electronic music, jazz and major international voices, offering an experience that combines top-tier concerts, closeness to the artist and a premium environment far from the typical mega-festival model.

The event also features a philanthropic component through the Starlite Foundation, which has raised millions of euros for international charitable projects, integrating philanthropy at the heart of its proposal.

This year, it will return from June to August, with definitive dates yet to be announced. Tickets will be available starting Thursday (Feb. 26). For more information on the lineup and to purchase tickets, visit the Starlite Occident’s website.

The announcement of Starlite Occident Marbella comes two months after the celebration of Starlite Occident Madrid, another event organized by Starlite Music Group. In its third edition, that concert series — held at IFEMA Madrid in December — hosted the first Billboard No. 1s Spain, a collaborative event between Grupo Starlite and Billboard featuring performances by Ana Mena, Pablo Alborán, Rozalén and more.


Billboard VIP Pass

OutKast has reached a settlement to end a lawsuit against an electronic dance music duo calling itself ATLiens – the same name as one of the hip hop duo’s best-known songs.

In court filings, attorneys for Big Boi (Antwan Patton) and André 3000 (André Benjamin) say they’ve “reached agreement on a general settlement framework” to resolve the case, in which they sued the lesser-known group in 2023 for infringing trademarks to the famed portmanteau.

“The parties are hopeful that the case will be fully resolved within ninety days … if not sooner,” lawyers for both sides write in the filing. Specifics of the settlement were not disclosed, and neither side immediately returned requests for more details.

Released in 1996, ATLiens is OutKast’s second studio album, featuring the same-named song as one of the singles from the LP. The album spent 33 weeks on the Billboard 200, while the title song reached No. 35 on the Hot 100 and spent 17 weeks on the chart.

Nearly two decades later, the duo went to court in 2023 against ATLiens, an Atlanta-based EDM that allegedly started using that name in 2012 and later registered it as a trademark. OutKast’s lawyers said the name (a combo of “aliens” and their hometown of Atlanta) was a novel linguistic term, and that rival group was confusing music fans by using it.

“The word ATLiens was invented by OutKast. Before OutKast created it, it was not used in the cultural lexicon and did not exist,” their lawyers wrote at the time. “Defendant’s use of the ATLiens mark is likely to cause confusion, to cause mistake, or to deceive the public.”

In filing the case, OutKast claimed that, thanks to the rival group’s elaborate stage costumes, fans might literally think they’re Big Boi and André 3000. “The duo comprising defendant performs with masks on, thereby concealing their identities such that consumers will mistakenly believe that the members of defendant are one and the same with – or at least somehow connected to – plaintiff.”

ATLiens responded in 2024, denying all wrongdoing and rejecting that OutKast has “any trademark rights whatsoever in the ATLIENS mark.” But the case has largely been paused for more than a year as the two sides worked on reaching a settlement.

The ongoing debate around so-called “walled gardens” in the music industry continues with a new open letter titled “Say No to Suno,” in which a number of artist rights groups call out the AI music company for its training practices and its approach to AI song downloads. “Suno built its business on our backs, scraping the world’s cultural output without permission, then competing against the very works exploited,” the letter reads.

Written for the blog The Trichordist, the letter was signed by the Music Artists Coalition, the European Composer and Songwriter Alliance, the Artist Rights Alliance, North Music Group, the Artist Rights Institute and the ECR Music Group — many of which are known for taking strong, pro-copyright stances.

Related

The discussion around whether AI music companies should implement walled gardens — or forbidding AI songs to exit the platform — has become a major point of discussion in recent weeks. In late January, Michael Nash, chief digital officer and executive vp at Universal Music Group, was interviewed on Billboard’s On the Record podcast and shared that Suno’s disinterest in making the service a walled garden is a reason why UMG has yet to settle its part of the major labels’ $500 million copyright infringement lawsuit against Suno. “That’s kind of a hat-hanger in this discussion,” he said.

Paul Sinclair, chief music officer at Suno, weighed in on the topic a few days later in a lengthy LinkedIn post titled Open Studios, Not Walled Gardens: “If we had tried to lock music into closed systems over the last 25 years, we wouldn’t have streaming as we know it.” He said that new innovations could spring from AI development, including new genres, “but for that promise to be real, these tools can’t just be toys inside a box.”

The activists’ letter disagrees with Sinclair’s argument. “At its core, Sinclair’s argument is just a tired remix of the old trope that ‘information wants to be free.’ What that really means is: ‘We want your music for free.’”

Related

The letter adds: “Ask yourself: just why are most gardens surrounded by fences or walls? To keep out rabbits, deer, raccoons and wild pigs seeking a free lunch. We cultivate, nurture and protect our gardens precisely because that makes them much more productive over the long run.”

Not all stakeholders believe in the “walled garden” approach. Warner Music Group, for example, found a settlement with Suno, ending its part of the major labels’ lawsuit against the AI music company, without forcing it into a closed environment. Instead, as part of the deal, Suno agreed to limit the number of downloads of AI music and users who want more downloads must pay extra. When asked about “walled gardens” on WMG’s latest earnings call, on Feb. 5, CEO Robert Kyncl said: “I think this issue is getting painted too much in black and white… Black and white is never the answer,” adding “it’s worth it to do the hard work of finding the equilibrium that creates value — we think we got it right.”

Spotify also does not appear to have an issue with AI music leaving its place of origin and ending up on their site: “A growing catalog has always been very good for us,” co-CEO Gustav Söderström said in reference to the rise of original AI-generated songs on a recent earnings call. “It attracts new users, drives engagement and builds fandoms … while the music may be generated on various AI platforms, the point is that regardless of where the music is made, the cultural moment always happens on Spotify.” 

Related

The group of activists also call out Suno’s training practices in the letter as well, alleging that Suno’s use of copyrighted songs as training data without a license is a “brazen rip-off of artists enabled by irresponsible AI… The hijacking of the world’s entire treasure-trove of music floods platforms with AI slop and dilutes the royalty pools of legitimate artists from whose music this slop is derived.”

The group also raises concerns about Deezer’s latest research, which says that up to 85% of all streams on fully AI generated music are fraudulent or artificial. “Suno has yet to demonstrate persuasively that its platform does not, in practice, serve as a scalable input into streaming-fraud schemes — raising a serious concern that Suno has, in effect, become a fraud-fodder factory on an industrial scale,” the letter reads.

Read the letter in full below:

Say No to Suno

Late last year, thieves disguised as construction workers broke into the Louvre during broad daylight, grabbed more than $100 million worth of crown jewels, and roared off on their motorbikes into the busy streets of Paris. While some of those thieves were later arrested, the jewelry they stole has yet to be recovered, and many fear those historic works of artistry have already been recut, reset, and resold.

Closer to home, but no less nefarious, is the brazen rip-off of artists enabled by irresponsible AI, whose profiteers are recutting, remixing, and reselling original works of artistry as something new. The hijacking of the world’s entire treasure-trove of music floods platforms with AI slop and dilutes the royalty pools of legitimate artists from whose music this slop is derived.

Meanwhile, those who are promoting this new business model are operating in broad daylight, too – minus the yellow safety vests. That is AI music company Suno, the brazen “smash and grab” platform whose “Make it Music” ad campaign suggests that the most personal and meaningful forms of music can now be fabricated by their unauthorized AI platform machinery trained on human artists’ work.

How significant is this activity? Publicly revealed data says Suno is used to generate 7 million tracks a day, a massive quantity that suggests a dominant market share of AI tracks. According to recent reports, Deezer “deems 85% of streams of fully AI-generated tracks [on its service] to be fraudulent,” and that such tracks include outputs from major generative models. As JP Morgan’s analysts said, Deezer’s data “should be indicative of the broader market.” Suno has yet to demonstrate persuasively that its platform does not, in practice, serve as a scalable input into streaming-fraud schemes — raising a serious concern that Suno has, in effect, become a fraud-fodder factory on an industrial scale.

In a February 2 LinkedIn post, Paul Sinclair, Suno’s Chief Music Officer, claims that his company’s platform is about “empowerment” that enables “billions of fans to create and play with music.” He argues that closed systems are “walled gardens” that deny people access to the full joy of music.

Ironically, Sinclair’s choice of analogy undermines his own argument. Ask yourself: just why are most gardens surrounded by fences or walls? To keep out rabbits, deer, raccoons and wild pigs seeking a free lunch. We cultivate, nurture and protect our gardens precisely because that makes them much more productive over the long run.

While Sinclair may be loath to admit it, AI is fundamentally different from past disruptive innovations in the music industry. The phonograph, cassettes, CDs, MP3s, downloads, streaming – all these technologies were about the reproduction and distribution of creative work. By contrast, irresponsible AI like Suno appropriates and plunders such creative work while undermining the commercial ecosystem for artists.

Think back to the days of Napster. What brought the music industry back from the ruinous abyss of unfettered digital piracy? It was the very “closed systems” that Sinclair derides as exclusionary. At least streaming platforms maintain access controls and content management systems that enable creator compensation, even if the economic outcomes for many creators remain inadequate. Should we be against Apple Music, Spotify, Deezer, YouTube Music, and Amazon Music? What about Netflix, Disney+ and HBO, too, while we’re at it?

At its core, Sinclair’s argument is just a tired remix of the old trope that “information wants to be free.” What that really means is: “We want your music for free.”

Artists need to understand Suno’s game. They are not putting technology in the service of artists; they are putting artists in the service of their technology. Every time artists’ creations are used by the platform, those creations have just unwittingly been contributed to the creation of endless derivatives of artists’ own work, not to mention AI slop, with limited or no remuneration back to the human creators. Suno built its business on our backs, scraping the world’s cultural output without permission, then competing against the very works exploited.

It’s also important to keep in mind that using Suno to generate audio output calls into question the copyrightability of whatever Suno creates. Most countries around the world including the US Copyright Office have been clear that generative AI outputs are largely ineligible for a copyright – meaning the economic value of the Suno creation lies solely with Suno, not with the artist using it. The only ones gaining empowerment from Suno are Suno themselves.

Many in our community are embracing responsible AI as a tool for creation, and as a means for fans to explore and interact with our artistry. That’s wonderful. But it’s not the same as creating an environment where AI-generated works sourced from our music are mass distributed to dilute our royalties or, worse yet, reward those actively seeking to commit fraud. Artists need to know the difference – all AI platforms are not the same, and Suno, which is being sued for copyright infringement, is not a platform artists should trust.

Responsible AI-generated music must evolve within a framework that respects and remunerates artists, enhances human creativity rather than supplants it, and empowers fans to engage with the music they love. At the same time, AI services must preclude mass distribution of slop and prevent fraudsters from destroying the very ecosystem that has been built to reward and sustain artists and audiences alike.

All of us, including billions of music fans, share an urgent, deep and abiding interest in protecting and rewarding human genius, even as AI continues to change our industry and the world in unimaginable ways. So in 2026, even as the Louvre continues to revamp its own approach to security, we in the arts must rise to confront those who would “smash-and-grab” our creativity for their own benefit.

Together, while embracing innovation, we must work to establish more effective safeguards – both legal and technological – that better promote and protect all creative artists, our intellectual property, and the spark of human genius.

Say no to Suno. Say yes to the beauty and bounty of the gardens that feed us all.

Signed:

Ron Gubitz, Executive Director, Music Artist Coalition

Helienne Lindvall, Songwriter and President, European Composer and Songwriter Alliance

David C. Lowery, Artist and Editor The Trichordist

Tift Merritt artist, Practitioner in Residence, Duke University and Artist Rights Alliance Board Member

Blake Morgan, artist, producer, and President of ECR Music Group

Abby North, President, North Music Group

Chris Castle, Artist Rights Institute